Michigan’s Medical Malpractice Tort Reform “The Juice Isn’t Worth The Squeeze”

Share this Article

I want to commend Norman D. Tucker, a Michigan medical malpractice attorney, for his insightful blog entry on the fallacy of “tort reform,” including caps on damages in medical malpractice cases.  Michigan first implemented caps on damages in 1994.  The insurance industry lobby said it was necessary to keep healthcare affordable, to prevent doctors from leaving the state, along with many other sound bites.  The practical reality is that healthcare expenses continued to climb, doctors were not leaving the state, the number of medical malpractice filings decreased by almost 80%, medical malpractice payouts decreased substantially, yet defense costs went up because more cases went to trial.  The insurance companies are the ones that profited the most off the backs of patients injured by medical malpractice.  Now, there are many patients in Michigan (and other states with caps), who have meritorious claims who can not find a lawyer to take their case because it is not feasible economically.

I am afraid we are seeing the exact same thing here in North Carolina since the implementation of caps on damages in 2011.  These sound bites employed by insurance companies (doctors are leaving the state, etc.), which are patently false, may sound good to the average citizen until they or a loved one are injured by the negligence of a medical care provider.  Then they discover they have no recourse.  It will be interesting to see how this plays out in North Carolina.  This lawyer believes the caps on damages violates the North Carolina Constitution.  However, the issue has not made its way up to the appellate courts and may not do so for several more years. 

KJW Logo
Attorney Kevin J. Williams at his desk in his Greensboro North Carolina office.
Attorney Kevin J. Williams at his desk in his Greensboro North Carolina office.

Your Journey to Justice Begins Here

We understand you may feel confused or fearful. We also know there is a way forward, and you are not alone. When you work with Kevin, your case isn't just a file; it's a chapter in your life story that needs careful, personalized attention. We're here to listen, to understand, and to guide you through the legal process with clarity and compassion.